Designing for the 1%: Why Edge Cases Aren’t Optional

Louise North 2025-11-29

Let’s talk about the other users. Not your typical, scroll-happy, ideal-case personas.

I’m talking about the people who use Internet Explorer 11 in 2025. The ones who type their name in all caps with seventeen emojis. The ones who have low vision, slow Wi-Fi, or a cracked phone screen from 2017. In UX lingo, these are your edge cases—and ignoring them is one of the quietest ways your product can fail.

We love designing for the “happy path.” The smooth, linear flow where everything works and everyone behaves. But the truth is, real users are messy, unpredictable, and full of surprises. And when your design assumes perfection, you’re setting yourself up to exclude people by default.

What Exactly Is an Edge Case?

In product design, an edge case is any scenario that falls outside the norm—situations you don’t design for first, but absolutely should design for eventually.

Examples:

  • The user with a 200-character last name.
  • Someone uploading a 5GB file on a rural connection.
  • A person using a screen reader in a different language.
  • A user who clicks “back” six times during checkout because they got nervous.

These aren’t bugs in human behavior. They’re real users with real needs.

The Cost of Ignoring Edge Cases

Designing only for your majority users creates a false sense of completion. It feels efficient. It’s fast. But it’s also fragile.

When you skip edge cases, you’re not just creating rare hiccups—you’re baking in exclusion:

  • People with disabilities get blocked or frustrated.
  • International users find the layout breaks when translated.
  • Low-income users suffer because your fancy animation crashes older devices.

Worse, you don’t usually hear from these users. They just leave. Quietly. Permanently.

Edge Cases Are Where Systems Break—and Where Innovation Lives

The beauty of edge cases is that they stress-test your assumptions.

That weird user who signs up with an emoji-only name? They expose how brittle your validation system is. That person trying to check out without a phone number? They force you to rethink required fields. These aren’t annoyances—they’re opportunities to make your product stronger, fairer, and more flexible.

Many of the web’s best innovations were born from solving for the edge:

  • Responsive design started with mobile—an edge case at the time.
  • ARIA attributes were created for screen readers.
  • Offline-first apps emerged for users with unreliable networks.

Edge case thinking makes better products for everyone.

So Why Are Edge Cases Treated Like Afterthoughts?

Because they’re inconvenient. They don’t show up in user journey maps. They’re hard to prototype. They break our perfect mockups. And—let’s be honest—they often don’t align with business metrics.

It’s easier to focus on the 99% that convert cleanly.

But that 1%? That’s where your design shows whether it’s resilient or just pretty.

How to Design for the Edges Without Losing Focus

No, you don’t need to obsess over every improbable scenario. But you do need a mindset shift:

  1. Identify your real edge cases early
    Look at analytics. Talk to support. Interview non-standard users. Ask: “Who’s struggling and why?”
  2. Build for flexibility, not perfection
    Don’t hardcode assumptions. Expect names with diacritics. Plan for missing profile pics. Accept unusual usage patterns.
  3. Test beyond the ideal path
    Use screen readers. Simulate slow networks. Break your own flows. Hire diverse testers.
  4. Design with empathy, not averages
    “Most users” is lazy thinking. Design like every user matters, not just the majority.
  5. Document your edge cases
    Add them to design specs. Share them in team standups. Normalize the idea that great UX accounts for the weird stuff.

The Edge Is the Center—You Just Didn’t See It

Here’s the real kicker: today’s edge case is often tomorrow’s norm.

What feels “fringe” now—like designing for neurodivergent users, multi-device workflows, or AI-based interaction patterns—may be standard within a year.

The more we design with the edges in mind, the more future-proof and inclusive our products become.

Because good design doesn’t just work under ideal conditions. It works when things get weird, messy, and human.

Next time someone says, “Oh, that’s just an edge case,” take a breath—and remind the

Designing for the 1% isn’t optional. It’s the difference between looking polished and actually being user-first.

Leave a Comment
Submitted successfully!

Recommended Articles